Originally posted by: Shanice
His reactions are very hurtful and make me realize even more that our relationship is severely damaged and not a good basis to start an open relationship at all.
Truer words have never been spoken. If the relationship is on a shaky foundation to begin with, making it an open relationship is adding gasoline to the fire. I'm a counselor, and I have been involved in three situations where marriages ended over "swinging" situations that began like this.
My experience has been that when one partner requests an open relationship, then that partner
usually already has someone in mind.
I don't think anyone on this website will say that "open" relationships are for everyone. Given how you feel about it, you're probably not going to be happy with the results. I agree with your assessment of the situation totally.
I think this is a conversation you have to have with him. Just don't let yourself be pressured into a situation that you aren't comfortable with. You're right; if the relationship is having problems to begin with, bringing in other people and other emotional connections is only going to magnify whatever problems already exist. Ultimately, this is a conversation that only you and he can have. Before you have that conversation with him, you need to get with a trusted friend who can help you make sure that you're clear about
your feelings before you start that conversation. If you go into that conversation without being clear about what you feel and what you want, then you'll end up agreeing to something then regretting it later.
Best wishes. Please let us know what happens. This is a difficult situation to face, and you're probably feeling that you have to choose between him and agreeing to something you don't feel is right. Make sure you don't agree to something you really don't feel is right in an attempt to preserve the marriage. That
always ends in heartbreak for everyone concerned. If you aren't totally convinced that an open relationship is what's right for
you, then you'll never be happy with the results.