I believe a word of caution would be the best way to start a response here… Having been in the Lifestyle for many years, I can assure you that jealousy is something that comes up with almost everyone at some point in the lifestyle and can cause huge problems if left unchecked, and while swinging can open up a couple to new heights when it comes to sexuality and sexual freedom, it can quickly and I mean very quickly destroy a relationship!
Now I am NOT one of those “Swingers” who believes that everyone should be in the lifestyle, In fact I believe 98% of all couples out there have no business in the lifestyle what so ever! In order for swinging to work BOTH partners need to be able to fully separate the act of having sex with the act of being in love and do so without Jealousy or nothing but bad things will come from your play time!
The next big part of a successful swinging experience is communication, which from the sounds of it, when it comes to sex; you and your husband do not have. If he can’t openly discuss his sexuality with you, then he will probably not be able to discuss the feelings that come along with inviting other people into your sex life.
Now you really have to ask yourself this question.. If he is bitter about sexual partners that you had prior to your marriage, do you really think that he will view swinging as a good thing? Most likely not regardless of what he says, and I find it ridiculous that he had forgiven you for having partners before him and doing that to him? That’s just nonsense and a real warning sign! What you did before him really doesn’t concern him. Sure full disclosure is nice but it’s really for informational purposes only he has NO say in it what so ever! You had a life before him, and should you no longer be together for some reason, you will have one after him. He needs to come to terms with that and grow up, were not in High School anymore.
As far as the “Keeping Score” this is total manipulative bullshit. It really just shows that he is not ready to undertake the path which you want him to go down. The lifestyle and relationships for that matter, are not about Keeping score, this isn’t a game where one of you wins and one of you looses.. It’s your marriage you both need to win or it’s not going to work.
If you plan on perusing this with him, I would take it slow, I mean really slow as this has every indication that it will have a disastrous outcome, and I would really beg you to reconsider! It takes a lot of communication to make the lifestyle work, and I mean a lot, and it just doesn’t sound like your husband is ready to talk about such things. In fact it sounds like he could use a good dose of counseling to overcome his past and to learn to better communicate.
And on a final note, DON’T surprise him with a 3some, although finding another female to join you may be much harder to do than you think, this is not something that you should surprise someone with, trust me it’s not like getting a puppy for your birthday!
I wish I had some magic words that I could say to make it so you could enjoy the lifestyle, but it really doesn’t look like your husband is ready for this and may never be. Remember you have 2000+ years of society and religion against you, but good luck!